It frustrates me to no end when I meet people who treat God as some sort of magic genie who is there to solve all of their problems, and bestow upon them a fabulous life of ease and wealth. I’m sure you know the types: you meet an old acquaintance at Target and start talking to them, only to get sucked into a conversation where they spend forty-five minutes whining and complaining that God isn’t giving them a new car/girlfriend/college education/better job/etc. This happened to me this weekend, and I normally enjoy religious discussions of the theological sort, where I get a chance to flex my intellectual muscles. (This is why I fit so well with the Catholic church; they really embrace the idea of intellect and reason applied to religion. Theology wins over blind faith any day.) Unfortunately, the conversation in which I ended up was far from a theological debate. It was almost an hour of me listening to this guy complain that God is not the magic genie that he expected.
The complaint centered around this guy’s long-standing desire for a girlfriend/wife, and God’s failure to provide. My first problem with the conversation was the guy’s attitude that God is merely some great invisible genie who is there to grant his every wish. All he has to do is go to church, pray a few prayers, go to “Bible study,” and God will grant his every wish. He doesn’t have to do anything–God does everything for him. Now, this guy attends one of those feel-good non-denominational churches; specifically, the huge “community church” off of I-45 that’s done up conspicuously like a mosque straight out of Mecca. (I’m sure the architects thought they were getting a synagogue or Jewish temple, but unfortunately for them the church looks nothing of the sort. My dad keeps calling it Mecca, which makes me laugh. A lot.) I can’t speak for ALL of those kinds of churches, but they seem to be a breeding ground for exactly this kind of feel-good, Genie-Jesus pseudo-theology. Joel Osteen is particularly fond of this kind of tripe, but I digress.
My second problem was the guy’s obvious religious illiteracy. If you read the Bible, and you really apply Christian theology to your life, God is not some sort of mysterious genie who answers all of your prayers and gives you a perfect life. Certainly, you shouldn’t be getting off so easily that all you have to do is go to church, say a few prayers, and pretend to study the Bible. The New Testament certainly doesn’t imply any kind of easy road to Heaven, so it boggles my mind that people can reduce the Bible to a magic lamp. What made the conversation more frustrating was the guy’s insistence that it was a combination of God failing to answer his prayers and society’s rejection of Christian morals that prevented him from having his prayers answered. God was somehow punishing him for not being good enough, for being too enmeshed in society, for not praying hard enough, and for a number of other imaginary sins.
Throughout the entire conversation, he never made any mention that he might have to change his lifestyle, his way of thinking, his relationship with God, before his prayers might be answered. So it didn’t matter that he was still living with his mom, had no car, no job skills, and his only job was sacking groceries part-time at Kroger’s. That didn’t matter at all–God’s failure to miraculously drop a girlfriend in his lap was God’s fault, either a punishment for his failure to be a good Christian, or God’s inability to answer his prayers in a timely manner. All he had to do was show up–God did the rest.
The worst part about this guy was when he asked me which church I attend. Yes, even though I’m a Godless Sinner, I still enjoy sitting in during mass at the Chapel of St. Basil on campus. I enjoy the beauty and simplicity of the mass given by the Basilian fathers. When I told him that I attend a Catholic church, he was taken aback and got visibly upset. “You’re a CATHOLIC!? But . . . they worship Mary! and the saints! They don’t even believe in God and Jesus! How can you believe that?” He was more concerned about that than the fact that his brother, who was “just a dirty atheist,” seemed to have a better life than he did. I wonder about that. He was obviously convinced that I was somehow less of a human because I was Catholic (which is technically true–I’m more of a Catholic-sympathizing atheist, if you want to get really technical), and that his particular brand of pseudo-theology was somehow vastly superior to nearly 2000 years of Biblical scholarship in the Catholic church. (Yeah, that gets misguided at times, but the Church itself generally promotes theological research.)
I really can’t respect this kind of religious thinking. If you’re serious about your religion, why do you treat it as some sort of simplistic wish-granting machine? I just can’t believe that people could take something that’s supposed to be a serious spiritual relationship and reduce it to the stuff of late-night info-mercials. “It slices, it dices, makes Julienne fries! It also smites your enemies, improves your sex life, and grants your every wish! Pray now and get a free gift! Make all checks payable to First Church of Genie-Jesus. No refunds!”
It’s very disconcerting, to say the least, despite the fact that I myself don’t believe. It’s one thing to embrace a spiritual faith and be happy with the eternal reward, but it’s quite another to embrace a faith simply because you expect a return, not just in the next life, but in this one as well. From my understanding, Christian life isn’t supposed to be easy. It’s not supposed to be just a wish-granting machine that makes your life easy without any effort. That’s not how it’s supposed to work, but that’s what people are expecting, and it upsets me greatly.
Of course, most of that frustration comes from the fact that it’s becoming more and more difficult to get a decent theological debate out of people because so many alleged Christians are embracing this kind of feel-good Genie-Jesus tripe. Going to church doesn’t make you a Christian any more than standing in a garage makes you a car. And as far as I’m concerned, this guy I ran into, and many others, are just standing in their garages waiting for God to wave a magic wand and make everything better. It doesn’t work that way.